People walking along street with a store displaying 'sale' signs in the background.
Bryant experts discuss how marketers get consumers to buy, where consumers are likely spending money this year, and how to be a smarter Black Friday shopper.

The science of the deal: Why Black Friday discounts are so hard to resist

Nov 20, 2026, by Bob Curley and Emma Zerman

Shoppers enjoy two things on Black Friday, says Economics Lecturer Liam Rice ’17: the product they purchase and the feeling of a good deal. 

“Black Friday is one of the best natural experiments in consumer behavior we have. Each year, millions of people face the same prices, the same deadlines, and the same marketing. Their choices reveal how far real behavior departs from the textbook model of a patient, fully informed shopper,” says Rice, who teaches Bryant's "Microeconomic Principles" and "Macroeconomic Principles" courses. 

In 2025, Americans spent $11.8 billion in online Black Friday sales, according to Adobe Analytics. This year, a report from CapitalOne Shopping predicts consumer purchasing online will grow to $12.9 billion. 

Both in-store and online holiday sales are growing, with online slightly higher than 4.2 percent and brick and mortar slightly lower than 4.2 percent year-over-year, says Teresa McCarthy Byrne, Ph.D., associate professor of Global Supply Chain Management and Marketing.  

“Overall, online sales account for about 16.5 percent of total retail. [In-store] is still the dominant channel, which is why the traditional ‘Black Friday’ is still a big event consumers enjoy, despite the holidays sale season now being expanded to ‘Black November,’” she says. 

Below, Rice, McCarthy Byrne, and Marketing Professor Sharmin Attaran, Ph.D., discuss how marketers get consumers to buy, where consumers are likely spending money this year, and how to be a smarter Black Friday shopper.  

What drives us to buy? 

Scarcity is one of the most effective tactics that marketers and advertisers use to prompt consumers to make purchases, says Attaran.  

“Countdown clocks and low-stock alerts trigger fear of missing out and loss aversion. Losing a deal feels worse than spending the money,” she says. “Discount depth matters, too. Shoppers want 40- to 50-percent off — anything that feels better than any other time of year.” 

Rice says that urgency works because it changes the question a shopper asks.

RELATED ARTICLE: 'None of it looks like an ad': Inside the multibillion-dollar industry of advertising to children

“Instead of ‘Do I need this?’ the shopper asks, ‘Can I afford to miss this?’” Rice says. “Behavioral economics tells us people feel a loss about twice as sharply as an equivalent gain. Theoretically, a rational shopper would value a dollar gain and a dollar lost at the same magnitude, but economic research continuously shows people hate loss more than they love gain.”  

He notes that retailers have learned to turn a purchase decision into a loss-avoidance decision, utilizing urgency. 
McCarthy Byrne adds that retailers are increasingly using AI and predictive analytics to generate targeted promotions.  

“These promotions help retailers better maintain margins by only discounting selected items rather than the entire store,” she says. “In addition, customers in all economic segments appreciate targeted messages and promotions that appeal to their preferences.” 

Where are consumers spending money? 

Durable goods tend to dominate consumer spending during Black Friday, says Rice. When a large, predictable discount arrives on a fixed date, it pays to time big-ticket purchases around it.  

“That is why televisions and appliances dominate. Consumers know they want a new laptop but can hold off on purchasing it immediately; they can look ahead to a Black Friday deal later in the year and wait to purchase it then,” Rice says. 

The categories people watch most are electronics, home appliances, winter clothing, and gifts, adds Attaran. This year, analyst forecasts are expecting households to stockpile toothpaste, diapers, and other household essentials on Black Friday.  

“That signals budget pressure: Shoppers are using Black Friday to manage the cost of living, not just to buy gifts,” Rice says.

RELATED ARTICLE: Stressed about the economy? Bryant psychologist provides tips on how to lessen money anxiety

Rice shares that, this Black Friday, one of the things he’s interested in seeing buy-now-pay-later (BNPL). The headline spending numbers will look healthy, but averages may hide a K-shaped consumer (someone whose spending as well as financial outcomes diverge based on income). 

"Higher-income households are spending comfortably while lower-income households trade down, stock up on essentials, and lean on buy now, pay later. I would watch BNPL volume closely; it smooths spending today but shifts the burden into January and February," he says. 

Rice also is paying attention to agentic shopping and whether that will impact Black Friday results. 

"With AI companies pushing AI agents to monitor deals and make purchases for consumers, will we see more spending due to automated purchasing or less spending due to removing human emotions out of the purchasing decision?" he asks. 

Impact of inflation 

Rice notes that, in today's economy, consumers' awareness of inflation has changed over the last year. They've recalibrated their reference prices upward, which gives retailers room to advertise headline discounts that feel generous but deliver less real value than they did a few years ago.  

"Inflation quietly erodes the Black Friday discount, even if the percent discount still looks great. A 20 percent markdown on a price that climbed 15 percent over the year leaves the shopper only slightly ahead of where they were last November. Suddenly the deal doesn’t look as good as it might feel," Rice says. 

RELATED ARTICLE: Will home prices ever come down? Here's what economists are watching

McCarthy Byrne says the rate of spending among lower income households is increasing, but less than the rate of inflation, "so they are acutely aware of promotions to stretch their dollar as far as possible."  

Attaran adds that some retailers are lowering the risk of buying in response to inflationary pressure, noting that many are offering longer return windows that run into January or February. “Shoppers can buy early, get through the holidays and travel, then return what didn't work.” 

Being a smarter Black Friday shopper 

Rice says that Black Friday matters more for revenue than for margins.  

"The advertised deals are often loss leaders. The profit comes from the full-price items shoppers add to their carts to complement the new TV or laptop they purchased at a discount," he says. "Strong Black Friday activity is more a signal of a company’s desirability from consumers, rather than a short-term profitability driver." 

But how can you tell the difference between a genuine deal and clever pricing?

Rice suggests ignoring the crossed-out price you see on the website since it could be an inflated anchor price. Instead, check the item’s price history over the past several months. If the “great deal” Black Friday price matches what it sold for in September, the discount is more likely marketing fluff rather than a genuine deal. 

“My advice is to make the decision before the sale, not during it,” Rice says. “Write your shopping list intentionally before you shop and set your budget in advance so you know your maximum spend amount. Then the discounts and deadlines work for you instead of against you.” 

Attaran advises consumers to make a list of what you actually need and stick to it.  

“The volume of sales is overwhelming, and it's easy to end up with duplicates,” she says.  “Use price history tools such as CamelCamelCamel, or the price history now built into Amazon, to check whether a deal is real. Stack savings with cash-back sites such as Rakuten. And remember the FOMO is by design: the day after Black Friday can feel gut-wrenching, but a deal you didn't need isn't a deal.”

Read More

Related Stories